 |
| Sadly, the world of clergical careerism described by Fr. Orsi has resulted in exactly this behavior. It's not at all funny. |
The following two pieces are from an America Magazine article on the Msgr Lynn conviction. The first is from Fr Michael P. Orsi, a fellow at the Ave Maria School of Law. It is an excerpt from the main article for which the second piece is a direct comment. The second part was written by Fr Francis J. Flynn a Phd. Psychologist practicing in the Miami area. It's not very often one comes across two commentaries which clarify what exists with what must change.
I start the first comment after Fr. Orsi's explanation of his personal knowledge of Msgr Lynn, and end it before Orsi's prescription for changing diocesan organizational structure in order to give more clergy and laity a sort of 'insiders' niche in the decisions of their bishops. Fr Flynn on the other hand, cuts to the chase.
......Bill is part of a hierarchical church that imposes obedience to the diocesan bishop on Her priests. It encourages priests to be team players. And it forces priests to seek affirmation and support within a diocesan structure. This system does not encourage challenges. As the old seminary saying goes, “You keep the rules and the rules will keep you.”
From
the moment of ordination a priest becomes intimately bound to his
bishop and the presbyterate of his diocese. The bishop has complete
control over a priest’s life, materially – for sure, and often times
spiritually on account of the decisions he makes in the priest’s
regard. Because of this priests look to their bishop as a father
figure. They want to believe that his decisions are wise.
A
great sign of success for a priest is to be invited to join the
Diocesan Curia, the bishop’s circle of collaborators in the
administration of the diocese. The position of Vicar for the Clergy,
the post held by Lynn from1990 – 2002, is just such a sinecure. (This is a 'sign of success' directly tied to careerism rather than pastoring the faithful. It's a point of view which Fr. Orsi either doesn't understand he's advocating, or he thinks is an acceptable and natural aspect of priesthood.)
In
this elite environment there are few priests who are willing to oppose
the bishop’s wishes for fear of falling out of favor.
Being
a team player is important for any organization. It is a vital part
of the clerical lifestyle. Camaraderie is strongly impressed upon
priests. We often refer to our fellow priests as our brothers. The
fact is that we do have a real dependency on each other since we do not
have an immediate family of our own. Priests rely on each other for
acceptance, for sharing the work load and even living arrangements.
If a priest deems any of these to be inadequate or unjust he may be,
rightly or wrongly, labeled a malcontent or a problem. This
perception can follow him throughout his priesthood.
Very often a priest, may have some very serious concerns, yet simply “Go Along to Get Along.”
Because
a priest’s circle is often limited to fellow priests his vision
may also be limited. Therefore, if there is a problem, in certain
cases, the advice he receives from them does not always come from
fresh or unbiased eyes. Defense mechanisms can also easily set in;
denial, rationalization and silence for self preservation. As one
wizened old priest said about speaking up or speaking out, “Who needs
the aggravation?”
Monsignor Lynn is
not innocent. He failed in his duty of care to children. His
punishment is harsh, and I pray that it will be reduced. It serves,
however, as a necessary message to bishops throughout the country that
the system needs fixing...... (Fr Orsi's fixes do not include any changes inherent to the priesthood he describes, which means they are not fixes. They are cosmetic.)
Now onto Fr Flynn's take:
Yes, Father Orsi. For more than 40 years you have been acquainted with “Inmate” or “Convict Lynn” – for that he what he is called now. (I know; I worked for eleven years in a maximum security prison.) But, truly, you do not know him. Or you are blindly self-deceiving when you say that he is “a good man and a good priest… a good soldier.” He lacked the personal integrity, the courage of Faith and Hope, that a true Christian, a genuinely “good priest” would exercise in refusing to be “a good soldier.” Rather, whether from blatant cowardice or because he had already sold his soul – and the souls of priests’ victims – he settled for “a sinecure.” History is replete with examples of individuals who lacked the personal fortitude, the courage, the integrity, indeed the spiritual and personal strength, necessary to say NO to those in authority. He is now a convict, condemned by a jury of his lay/civilian peers to a prison sentence he richly deserves. (It has always seemed to me that the abuse crisis got so out of hand precisely because the clerical system doe not believe laity are peers or that civil society has a right or is competent to address criminal clergy. The theology behind the system was designed to convince laity of the same 'truth.)
Unfortunately, you have missed the point. A cowardly and self-serving man, who was afraid to lose the benefits of rectory and health insurance, of cooks and housekeepers who do his bidding, deluded himself – and, perhaps, others – into believing that he was serving the institution to which he had sold his manhood and his soul. Unless he had completely given in to his delusions, he knew in the depth of his soul that he was guilty of the crucifixion of the Christ who dwells within the souls of victims and the families of the victims of “predator priests.” Father Orsi, Convict/Prisoner/Inmate Lynn is where his choices have brought him. His punishment is not “harsh.” If, as I have, you have spent not a few but hundreds and hundreds of hours talking with and counseling adult male survivors of childhood sexual abuse, you would know that Convict Lynn’s punishment is not “harsh.” Three years, even six years of incarceration – with “three hots and a cot” – is miniscule when compared to the uncountable decades of pain lived by the victims of those whom Convict Lynn unleashed upon them. Do not pray that his punishment “will be reduced.” If you pray for Inmate Lynn, if his bishop and his fellow priests pray for him at all (and, I can tell you that “out of sight is out of mind” for inmates), pray that at the end of his sentence he emerge from his deserved incarceration as a man of new found integrity, who will no longer remain silent about the injustices of those to whom he has sworn undeserved loyalty.
Father Orsi, your “attempt to help people understand why he acted as he did” does little more than illustrate the deplorable pathologies to which the priesthood has devolved. Your “suggestion” does little to excise the cancer that is the clericalism that you described and seemingly justified. If you truly wish to encourage a new and healthy priesthood cut out the malignancy completely. Begin by encouraging the American Church to require that all candidates for the priesthood enter formation/religious life only after having established themselves in professional careers and lives through which they can sustain themselves – without having to surrender “complete control” “materially – for sure, and often times spiritually.” Sure, this will mean that more mature men will enter the ministry, but, hopefully, they will be men who will not sell their souls for a sinecure. Pay priests honest salaries equivalent to that of the average salaries of teachers in their diocesan Catholic high schools. Provide them with the same health insurance as a Catholic grade school teacher. Abolish the enforced mechanism of slavery that is rectory living – at every level of clerical life from diaconate to episcopacy. Let priests and bishops learn to cook their own meals, wash their own clothes, struggle to pay their own rents and car expenses. In short, make the Priesthood of Service a vocation rather than a source of entitlements. And, yes, this will mean an ever decreasing number of priests to serve an ever increasing number of parishioners. As a result, if the hierarchy truly prizes the Eucharist as it says it does, it will be forced to honestly reconsider the very nature of our priestly vocations. Here is my promise to you. I will periodically pray for Convict Lynn. I will pray that he emerges incarceration as a truly independent, free, honest and courageous man. If he does so, he will have earned the right to speak the truth and “to oppose the bishop’s wishes” without “fear of falling out of favor.” Rev. Francis J. Flynn, Psy.D., Miami, Florida
**********************************************
At the end of his comment Fr Flynn makes the same point I have been making on this blog for over four years. If the Eucharist is the summit of Catholic existence, then it's beyond time our leadership put some money where their mouth is because one thing the abuse crisis has served to underscore is that the Sacrament of Ordination trumps the Sacrament of Holy Communion. Ordination is the pinnacle of Catholic expression, not the Eucharist. It is the priesthood which will be protected at all costs, not the Eucharist.
Until that changes, nothing else in Catholicism can be reformed.
